Etsy Messaging Policy: Can You Message Past Buyers About a Sale?
Etsy's messaging policy bans unsolicited promotions in Messages, even to past buyers. What Etsy said about Cyber Specials, and what to do if you sent one.
No. Under the Etsy messaging policy, you can't send past buyers a message advertising your Cyber Specials sale, or any other sale they didn't ask to hear about. Etsy's Seller Policy lists "Sending unsolicited advertising or promotions, requests for donations, or spam" among the things Messages may not be used for, and that line is still there today.
The confusion comes from Etsy itself. According to a Value Added Resource report, a November 6 message from Etsy told sellers to message past buyers about Cyber Specials, and a November 9 follow-up called that advice incorrect. If you already sent those messages, the rest of this post covers what Etsy can do about them and what to do now.
What Etsy told sellers, and what it took back
I couldn't find either message posted publicly by Etsy, so everything in this section comes from Value Added Resource, which quoted both in a report published November 9 and updated November 12.
According to that report, Etsy's November 6 message encouraged sellers who took part in last year's Cyber Specials to sign up again and to send "a warm note through Convos" to past buyers saying their shop was part of the sale. It also told them to head to Convos in Shop Manager and let past buyers know about the discounts coming their way.
Three days later, per the same report, Etsy sent a correction. It restated the first message as having encouraged sellers "to contact past buyers through Etsy Messages," and said: "This advice was incorrect." The reason it gave was that Etsy's policies prohibit unsolicited advertising or promotions through Messages. Etsy apologized and pointed sellers to shop announcements and social media instead.
What the correction didn't do, according to Value Added Resource, is say whether sellers who had already followed the first message would be protected from spam enforcement. As of the report's November 12 update, Etsy hadn't said. I searched Etsy's Help Center on November 13 and found no article that mentions the November 6 advice.
So you have two messages from the same company pointing in opposite directions. The one that matters is the written policy, because that's what Etsy's enforcement terms point to.
What the Etsy messaging policy actually says
The rule sits in Etsy's Seller Policy, which was last updated on October 5, 2026. It shows up in three separate places, and all three point the same way.
The first is the Messages section. It says Messages are "a great way for buyers to ask you questions about an item or an order," then lists what Messages may not be used for. The first item on that list is "Sending unsolicited advertising or promotions, requests for donations, or spam." The same list also bans "Contacting someone after they have explicitly asked you not to" and "Facilitating or directing off-platform transactions."
The second is the content rule that covers everything you upload, which explicitly includes Messages. You agree not to upload content that "Contains unsolicited advertising or promotions, requests for donations, or spam."
The third is the privacy section, which covers what you can do with a buyer's details. Information you get from a transaction "may only be used for Etsy-related communications or for Etsy-facilitated transactions," and you "may not use this information for unsolicited commercial messages."
None of this is new. The version of the Seller Policy archived on January 1, 2020, last updated on June 25, 2019, has the same Messages line word for word. The rule was in place for years before the November 6 message, as Value Added Resource reported it, suggested otherwise.
There's no exception in the policy for repeat customers. Nothing in the text treats someone who bought from you last year differently from a stranger. The help article on how to send messages to buyers frames contacting a buyer around their order: "If you need to contact a buyer about an order, you can send a message to them."
If you've read our breakdown of Etsy's off-platform violation rules, this is the same Messages list. Directing a buyer off Etsy and announcing a sale to a buyer who didn't ask are two different items on it, and both are prohibited.
What "unsolicited" means for a buyer who already bought from you
The Seller Policy doesn't define "unsolicited." That's the word doing all the work here, so it's worth looking at the closest thing Etsy has published.
Etsy's Seller Handbook article on writing privacy policies for your shop has a section on marketing messages. It opens with what to know "before using email addresses to contact your buyers," and says that under the laws of many countries you often need prior "express consent" from buyers before sending them marketing or promotional messages. Its example of how a buyer gives that consent is "a buyer agreeing in an Etsy Convo or email to receive marketing messages from you." It then adds: "Even if you get a buyer's email address through Etsy to help fulfill the transaction, you're required to get the buyer's express consent before sending them marketing messages." It also says you have to respect requests to opt out, because consent can be revoked at any time.
The same section says directly: "Keep in mind that sending unsolicited advertising or promotions through Etsy Convos is not allowed under Etsy's policies." It adds that it is "also a criminal offense in some countries."
Here's how I read that for Messages, and it's my reading rather than anything Etsy has spelled out. The Handbook is talking about email there, but the same idea carries over: having a buyer's details from an order isn't the same as their consent to hear about sales. A buyer who wrote to you asking to be told when you restock or run a sale has asked for that message. A list of everyone who ordered from you last year has not.
If you want to be able to tell a buyer about future sales, the safe version is the one the Handbook describes: they agree first through a clear affirmative action, such as saying yes in a Convo or email, and you stop the moment they tell you to.
What Etsy can do about a promotional message
Etsy reads Messages with software. Its Help Center article on how Etsy scans and reviews messages lists "Detect and prevent spam and scams" among the reasons, says Etsy uses automated tools to scan and filter messages, and says, "In some cases, we block messages."
The consequence Etsy spells out for spam is a mute. Etsy's article on why messages get muted says that if Etsy determines a certain amount of the messages you've sent are spam, "your messages will be muted for 48 hours." While muted, "you can't send any messages to other Etsy users." You find out by email from Etsy's Trust & Safety team, and "Etsy support agents are unable to reverse this temporary mute."
The article doesn't say how many spam messages it takes. What it does make clear is the cost: "any messages" includes the buyer whose order is late and the buyer asking about personalization.
Buyers have a button too. Etsy's help article on phishing scams gives the steps for reporting a message in the Etsy app, the Etsy Seller app and on Etsy.com, and says that once a message is reported, "You won't receive any new messages from that member in your inbox, and they'll be unable to reply to messages in an existing thread." The article is written for any member who reports a message, so a buyer who reports yours is out of reach, even in an existing thread, unless they later choose Not Spam.
Beyond Messages, the Seller Policy has its general enforcement line. If Etsy has reason to believe you or your content violate its Terms, including the Seller Policy, it "may deactivate Your Content to some or all users, or suspend or terminate your account." As of November 13, Etsy hasn't said publicly how, or whether, it will apply any of this to messages sent between November 6 and November 9.
If you already sent Cyber Specials messages to past buyers
As of November 13, Etsy hasn't publicly told sellers what to do, so this part is my advice, not Etsy's.
Stop sending them. Don't finish the list, and don't send a second round to explain or apologize. A message saying "sorry about my last message" is another unsolicited message to the same people.
Answer buyers who write back. If a past buyer replies asking about the sale, they've started the conversation, and answering a question is what Messages are for. Keep the reply to what they asked.
Keep both Etsy messages. Save the November 6 message and the November 9 correction somewhere outside your inbox, with their dates. If your messaging is ever limited over this, they show where the instruction came from. They won't undo a mute, since support agents can't reverse one, but they're the only record you have.
Clear your order messages early. A 48-hour mute blocks every outgoing message. If you have personalization questions or address checks waiting, send those now rather than in the week of Cyber Specials, when a mute would land at the worst time.
Don't move the list to email. Etsy's Seller Policy says you may not add any Etsy member to your email or physical mailing list without the buyer's consent. Emailing last year's buyers about the sale is the same problem through a different channel.
Ways to reach past buyers that Etsy does allow
Etsy has a few channels of its own for this. Two of them, the shop announcement and social media, are where the correction pointed sellers, according to Value Added Resource.
Targeted "Thank you" offers. Etsy's help article on sales and discounts describes four kinds of targeted offers, which Etsy emails to shoppers who are opted in to marketing emails. One of them is "Thank you": after a buyer has purchased from you, Etsy sends them a targeted offer email "to encourage them to buy from you again." It goes out after the order is completed, and the offer expires a year after it's sent. The article doesn't say whether buyers whose orders were completed before you set up the offer get one. The other three cover abandoned carts, favorited items and interested shoppers. Some buyers opt out of Etsy marketing emails, so not every eligible buyer gets one.
Your shop announcement. Etsy's article on adding a shop announcement says you can update it "to alert shoppers to important information like a sale." It appears under the listings on your shop homepage, so it reaches people who visit, not people who don't.
Social media. Etsy's article on promoting your shop describes a Social Media tool that lets you share "updates, milestones, or promotions happening in your shop" to sites like Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest and X, and its list of things to share includes active or upcoming sales and coupons. If past buyers follow you there, that's where they hear about the sale.
Your own mailing list, with consent. The Seller Policy's line here is about consent: without the buyer's consent you may not add them to your mailing list, and "you're responsible for knowing the standard of consent required in any given instance." The Handbook describes express consent as the buyer agreeing through "a clear affirmative action," and says you have to honor opt-outs.
Setting up Cyber Specials without the message
The sale itself is the part Etsy actually wants you in. Its help article on participating in sales events says Cyber Specials run from November 23 to December 1. To be considered for Etsy's marketing features, you had to opt in by October 27 and offer at least 25% off (Etsy gives a separate figure for the UK). Before you commit to a discount that deep, check your break-even price: below it, every sale loses money once Etsy's fees and the costs you enter are counted.
Missing that date doesn't keep you out. The same article says you can join a sales event even after it has started, by setting up a sale under Marketing, then Sales and discounts, then "Join Etsy's next sales event." Once the sale is set up, items are discounted automatically and buyers don't need a code. Etsy says participating shops may appear in Etsy marketing and "can be included in search results related to the sale."
One more policy line worth reading before you pick a discount. The Seller Policy says "Sales, discounts, and price comparisons must reflect real, accurate pricing," and "Promotions should not mislead buyers about the value or timing of a deal." The sales events article is blunter: you can't raise a price and then lower it to make it look like a sale, and "The original price for an item must be in place for a substantial amount of time." If you nudged prices up in October, look at that before November 23.
The short answer, again
The Etsy messaging policy hasn't changed: Messages can't be used for unsolicited advertising or promotions, so promoting a sale to buyers who didn't ask for it is prohibited, even when the sale is Etsy's own and even after Etsy, according to Value Added Resource, told sellers to do it. Use the shop announcement, your social accounts and Etsy's targeted offers to reach buyers, and keep Messages for orders.
If you're rewriting titles and descriptions for the sale anyway, ListingSafe's listing optimizer gives you a search score, a rewritten title, up to 13 tags and description, and a trademark and policy check. If you'd rather go through the whole shop first, a full shop trademark audit lays out the steps.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I message past buyers on Etsy about a sale?
Not unless they asked to hear about it. Etsy's Seller Policy lists "Sending unsolicited advertising or promotions, requests for donations, or spam" among the things Messages may not be used for, and it makes no exception for people who bought from you before.
Did Etsy really tell sellers to message past buyers?
According to Value Added Resource, which quoted both messages, a November 6 Etsy message encouraged sellers to message past buyers about Cyber Specials, and a November 9 follow-up said the advice was incorrect and apologized. I couldn't find either message posted publicly by Etsy.
What happens if Etsy decides my messages are spam?
Etsy's Help Center says that if it determines a certain amount of your messages are spam, your messages are muted for 48 hours, you can't send messages to anyone during that time, and support agents can't reverse it. Etsy's article on phishing scams adds that once someone reports a message, they won't receive new messages from that member in their inbox and the member can't reply in an existing thread, so a buyer who reports your message is out of reach unless they choose Not Spam.
Can I email my past Etsy buyers instead?
Not without their consent. The Seller Policy says buyer information from a transaction may only be used for Etsy-related communications or Etsy-facilitated transactions, and that you may not add an Etsy member to your mailing list without the buyer's consent.
How can I tell past buyers about my Cyber Specials sale?
Etsy's own options are a shop announcement, sharing the promotion through Etsy's Social Media tool, and targeted offers, including the "Thank you" offer that Etsy emails to buyers after a completed order if they're opted in to marketing emails.
SOURCES
- Etsy Seller Policy (last updated Oct 5, 2026)
- Etsy Seller Handbook — how to write on-point privacy policies
- Etsy Help — how to send messages to buyers
- Etsy Help — how and why Etsy scans and reviews messages
- Etsy Help — why were my messages muted?
- Etsy Help — how to help protect yourself from phishing scams
- Etsy Help — how to set up sales and discounts for your shop
- Etsy Help — how to add a shop announcement and shop title
- Etsy Help — how to promote your Etsy shop
- Etsy Help — how to participate in sales events on Etsy
Written by Wayne Chiu, who builds ListingSafe and writes about Etsy trademark compliance.
Scan your listings before publishing
ListingSafe checks your title, description, and tags for trademarked brand names before you publish.
Try ListingSafe free with GoogleRight on Etsy
Open any Etsy listing to see its real tags, trademarks marked red, and optimize it without leaving Etsy.
Add to Chrome — It's Free